The case concerned a Russian Chechen applicant for which the Administrative Tribunal of Toulouse decided that he could not be returned to Poland. The State appealed to the Council of State stating that the judge wrongly interpreted French law and that (European) Community legislation permitted the return to Poland. The Council of State found that “the constitutional right to asylum, which has as its corollary the right to apply for refugee status, is one of the fundamental freedoms mentioned in Article L.521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice, that the implementation of this right implies the possibility, by the French authorities, to ensure the processing of an asylum application even when international or Community law allows it to entrust this examination to another State”.